๐ŸŸ 

Prof. Giacomo Novara โ€” Urology, University of Padova

Benign Scrotal Pathology

Varicocele ยท Acute scrotum ยท Spermatic cord torsion ยท Epididymo-orchitis

Benign scrotal pathology encompasses two clinically very different domains: varicocele โ€” the leading treatable cause of male infertility โ€” and the acute scrotum, which includes spermatic cord torsion, a true urological emergency in which the time available to save the gonad is measured in hours.
Part I โ€” Varicocele

๐Ÿ”ฌ Definition and pathophysiology

Varicocele is the abnormal dilatation and tortuosity of the veins of the pampiniform plexus, secondary to reversal of flow in the internal (more frequently) or external spermatic veins. It is the scrotal equivalent of varicose veins of the lower limbs.

Why it is predominantly left-sided

The left spermatic vein drains into the left renal vein at a right angle: this creates a higher hydrostatic column and greater resistance to outflow. The right spermatic vein drains directly into the inferior vena cava at an acute angle. This anatomical asymmetry explains the marked left-sided predominance of varicocele. In large left-sided varicoceles, transverse communications (cross-communications) between the two venous systems may feed a contralateral varicocele: correcting left-sided reflux often also reduces the degree of right-sided varicocele.

Phlebographic classification (types 1โ€“5)

The classification describes anatomical variants of the left gonadal venous drainage. The so-called "type 1" (single gonadal vein draining at right angles into the renal vein) is present in only 40% of individuals โ€” the majority present variants with multiple veins, capsular collaterals, or duplicated renal veins. This variability is relevant for treatment planning.

๐Ÿ“‹ Who to treat โ€” and who not to

Varicocele in itself is not a condition that always requires treatment. There are patients with enormously dilated veins and a normal semen analysis: I do not treat them. And patients with a small varicocele and a dismal semen analysis: I treat them. The decision criterion is the semen analysis, not the degree of dilatation.

โœ… Treat

Patient with varicocele AND dyspermia documented on semen analysis AND interest in fertility. Treatment aims to improve seminal parameters (count, motility, morphology) and the probability of pregnancy.

๐Ÿ‘ Monitor

Varicocele with normal semen analysis โ†’ surveillance. Varicocele in minors (<14 years) โ†’ semen analysis not available; management is guided by degree of dilatation and testicular volume.

๐Ÿšซ Do not treat

Patient with no interest in fertility โ†’ diagnosing and treating a condition whose only implications are for fertility makes no sense. Partner >40 years and/or severely compromised semen analysis โ†’ refer directly to assisted reproductive technology.

โš ๏ธ Pain: caution

Pain from varicocele is rarely an independent indication for treatment. Pain often persists after correction. Treatment is indicated only when dyspermia is also present: if pain also improves, so much the better; if it persists, the patient has been forewarned.

๐Ÿ” Diagnosis

1
Physical examination in the standing position

Palpation of the spermatic cord during the Valsalva manoeuvre: in advanced grades (G3โ€“G4) the veins are visible on simple inspection. In lesser grades, the classic "bag of worms" sensation is felt.

2
Scrotal colour Doppler ultrasound

It is not sufficient to detect dilated veins: the examination must document reflux within these veins during Valsalva. Venous diameter >3 mm with confirmed reflux establishes the diagnosis. It also allows assessment of testicular volume (hypotrophy = already established damage).

3
Semen analysis (adults only)

The fundamental examination and primary decision criterion. Assesses count, progressive motility, and morphology of spermatozoa according to WHO criteria. Cannot be requested in minors for legal reasons.

โš•๏ธ Treatment

The objective is to correct reflux in the gonadal veins to improve seminal function. Both antegrade (from below, via the scrotal route) and retrograde (from above, via an endovascular route) approaches are available.

๐Ÿฉบ
Antegrade sclerotherapy (scrotal approach)

Under local anaesthesia, a ~1.5 cm scrotal incision is made, the spermatic cord is isolated, a vein of the pampiniform plexus is cannulated, phlebography confirms the anatomy, then air (1 mL) + sclerosant agent (3โ€“4 mL) is injected with the cord clamped distally. Outpatient procedure, duration ~10 minutes. Can treat any anatomical variant. Failure rate ~10%.

๐Ÿ”ฌ
Retrograde sclerotherapy (interventional radiology)

Femoral or brachial access, catheterisation of the left renal vein, cannulation of the gonadal vein, sclerotherapy from above. Efficacy comparable to the antegrade approach, but more difficult in anatomical variants with multiple gonadal veins draining separately into the renal vein.

Guidelines consider the two techniques equivalent. The antegrade scrotal approach may offer a practical advantage in complex anatomical variants, allowing all veins of the plexus to be reached regardless of their number and confluence into the renal vein.

๐Ÿ“Š Treatment outcomes

~37%
Patients achieving spontaneous pregnancy after correction
ร—2
Doubling of ART pregnancy rate after varicocele correction
6 months
Minimum time to assess semen analysis improvement
~10%
Sclerotherapy failure rate (residual varicocele)

Treatment improves sperm count, motility, and morphology. Approximately 37% of patients achieve spontaneous pregnancy; in the remainder, correction of varicocele doubles the success rate of assisted reproductive techniques compared with untreated patients. Correction is therefore also useful as preparation for ART, with the exception of cases where the partner is of advanced age or the semen analysis reveals complete azoospermia.

Part II โ€” Acute Scrotum

๐Ÿšจ Causes of the acute scrotum

The acute scrotum is the scrotal equivalent of the acute abdomen: acute scrotal pain with possible swelling and erythema. Three main causes account for over 90% of cases:

โฑ๏ธ
Spermatic cord torsion

Urological emergency. Progressive testicular ischaemia. Time is the critical factor: beyond 24 hours the gonad is lost. Requires immediate treatment.

๐Ÿฆ 
Epididymo-orchitis

Acute infective-inflammatory process of the testis and epididymis. Frequently associated with fever and urinary symptoms. Medical treatment (antibiotics).

๐Ÿ”ต
Torsion of the appendix testis (Morgagni hydatid)

Torsion of a functionless embryological remnant of the Wolffian duct. Clinically benign. Conservative management (analgesia).

๐Ÿšซ The error to avoid: in the acute scrotum, do not prescribe antibiotics + analgesia and review the patient "in a few days". If the diagnosis of spermatic cord torsion is delayed, the testis undergoes necrosis. Anyone unable to exclude torsion must refer the patient urgently to a centre capable of doing so.

โฑ๏ธ Spermatic cord torsion โ€” urological emergency

Pathophysiology

Involuntary contraction of the cremaster muscle causes rotation of the testis on its own axis (from 180ยฐ up to 720ยฐ). This first obstructs venous outflow, then compromises arterial inflow โ†’ progressive and irreversible testicular ischaemia. The damage is proportional to the degree of torsion and the time elapsed.

A distinction is made between intravaginal torsion (the most common in young adults: the testis rotates within the tunica vaginalis) and extravaginal torsion (typical of the neonate). The predisposing factor is testicular hypermobility due to inadequate fixation of the inferior pole to the scrotal wall.

Time window to save the testis

โ‰ˆ100%
Within 6 hours โ€” orchidopexy almost always possible
50%
Between 6 and 12 hours โ€” halved probability of saving the gonad
โ‰ˆ0%
After 24 hours โ€” testicular necrosis almost certain

Clinical presentation and differential diagnosis

Spermatic cord torsion

Violent pain of sudden onset (often nocturnal). No fever, no voiding symptoms. Hypermobile testis, riding higher than the contralateral side. Altered epididymo-testicular anatomical relationships if torsion is not a multiple of 360ยฐ. History of similar self-limiting episodes in the past (subtorsions).

Epididymo-orchitis

Less abrupt onset of pain. Fever present. Urinary symptoms (dysuria, frequency). Indurated and tender epididymis. Warm and erythematous scrotum. Colour Doppler: hyperaemia.

Appendix testis torsion

Pain at the upper pole of the testis, less intense. Normal testis on palpation. The "blue dot" sign occasionally visible (rarely). Colour Doppler: normal intraparenchymal flow, absent flow within the appendix.

๐Ÿ”ฌ Scrotal colour Doppler ultrasound โ€” the key investigation

Colour Doppler ultrasound is the decisive examination. The contralateral healthy testis is always studied first to calibrate Doppler parameters, then the affected side is examined. Normal intraparenchymal flow is 1โ€“2 mm/s.

Spermatic cord torsion
Absent flow

No intratesticular vascular signal on Doppler. This is the most decisive finding. If absent compared to the contralateral side โ†’ torsion until proven otherwise.

Epididymo-orchitis
Vascular hyperaemia

Marked increase in Doppler signal at the epididymis and testis due to acute inflammation. Reactive hydrocele frequently associated.

Appendix testis torsion
Preserved parenchymal flow, avascular appendix

Regular intraparenchymal flow. The appendix at the upper pole appears hyperechoic and devoid of vascular signal. No surgical urgency.

๐Ÿ“Œ Safety principle: in doubtful cases, surgical exploration is always preferable to watchful waiting. "Exploring a healthy testis is not a problem. Failing to explore a torted testis means condemning it to necrosis." If Doppler is inconclusive, explore.

๐Ÿ”ง Treatment of spermatic cord torsion

๐Ÿ–๏ธ Manual detorsion โ€” first attempt

Mechanism: testes rotate in a lateral-to-medial direction (from the thigh towards the midline). Detorsion is performed in the opposite direction: medial-to-lateral (from the midline towards the thigh).

In practice: right testis โ†’ detorsion clockwise (as seen by the patient); left testis โ†’ detorsion counter-clockwise.

Verification: pain relief is immediate. Confirmed by colour Doppler: flow must resume, often with reactive hyperaemia.

Limitation: most effective if the patient presents within a few hours. After successful detorsion, elective orchidopexy should be planned (adult) or performed the same day (child).

1
Manual detorsion

Immediate attempt. If successful (pain relief + restoration of Doppler flow) โ†’ bilateral orchidopexy planned electively or on the same day.

2
Urgent surgical exploration (if manual detorsion unsuccessful or diagnosis uncertain)

Median scrotal incision of 3โ€“4 cm. Opening of the tunica vaginalis, assessment of testicular viability. If viable โ†’ detorsion + bilateral orchidopexy (fixation of the inferior pole of both testes to the scrotal wall). If necrotic โ†’ orchiectomy (the necrotic testis must be removed to prevent the formation of anti-sperm autoantibodies that would damage the contralateral gonad).

3
Bilateral orchidopexy

Fixation must be performed on both sides: the hypermobility that caused the torsion is often bilateral. Preventing contralateral torsion is as important as saving the affected testis.

๐Ÿฆ  Epididymo-orchitis โ€” treatment

Infective-inflammatory process of the testis and epididymis. In the majority of cases the causative organism is a urinary tract or sexually transmitted pathogen.

โš ๏ธ Fluoroquinolones are no longer used empirically. Resistance to ciprofloxacin and levofloxacin in our geographical area exceeds 20โ€“25%: one in four patients does not receive effective therapy. Recommended alternative:

Acute phase (5 days): ceftriaxone 1 g i.m. (third-generation cephalosporin).
Oral phase (10 days): oral cephalosporin.
Total coverage of approximately 2 weeks.

Mild-to-moderate cases can be managed in the outpatient setting with oral therapy alone. Aggressive cases (high fever, systemic signs, scrotal cellulitis) require hospitalisation and parenteral therapy.

๐Ÿ”ต Appendix testis torsion โ€” treatment

The appendix testis (Morgagni hydatid) is an embryological remnant of the Wolffian duct with no functional role whatsoever. Its torsion and necrosis has no functional or reproductive clinical relevance.

Treatment: conservative. Analgesia and, where indicated, anti-inflammatory agents. Surgical exploration is not required when the colour Doppler diagnosis is certain. The appendix will resorb spontaneously over several weeks.

โ“ Frequently asked questions

Not necessarily. Varicocele should not be treated simply because it is present. The primary criterion for deciding whether to treat it is the semen analysis: if seminal parameters are normal, the varicocele is monitored over time without intervention. If, however, the semen analysis shows a reduction in sperm count, motility, or morphology, and you are interested in having children, then treatment is indicated. The procedure is minimally invasive (a small scrotal incision under local anaesthesia, duration ~10 minutes) and is performed as an outpatient. Results are assessed after approximately 6 months.
Acute and intense testicular pain of sudden onset is a urological emergency until proven otherwise. The most dangerous cause is spermatic cord torsion: the testis rotates on itself, cutting off its blood supply. If not treated within 6 hours, the gonad may suffer irreversible necrosis. Do not wait to see if it passes by itself and do not accept a prescription for antibiotics without excluding torsion: go to the emergency department immediately for urgent evaluation with scrotal ultrasound.
Varicocele may cause a sense of heaviness or scrotal discomfort, particularly after prolonged standing or intense physical activity. It rarely causes true acute pain. The problem is that even after varicocele correction, the discomfort often persists โ€” because it may have other contributing causes. For this reason, pain alone is usually not a sufficient indication for treatment. If there is also an abnormal semen analysis, intervention is undertaken to improve fertility, and the patient is informed that pain may improve but is not guaranteed to do so.
Approximately 37% of patients treated for varicocele achieve spontaneous pregnancy within 12โ€“18 months following treatment. This is a significant result, even if not guaranteed. The probability depends on many factors: the extent of baseline seminal damage, the partner's age (the most important factor), and the presence of any female fertility component. In patients who do not achieve spontaneous pregnancy, improvement in seminal parameters after varicocele correction doubles the success rate of assisted reproductive techniques.
An episode of intense and sudden scrotal pain that resolves spontaneously may represent a "subtorsion": torsion of the testis that detorted on its own, perhaps because the patient touched himself and inadvertently untwisted the spermatic cord. This is an important sign not to be ignored: those who have experienced such an episode are at risk of a complete torsion in the future. It is important to be assessed by a urologist to plan a preventive orchidopexy (fixation of the testis to the scrotal wall), which prevents recurrence.

๐Ÿ”— Related topics